Conexiant
Login
  • Corneal Physician
  • Glaucoma Physician
  • New Retinal Physician
  • Ophthalmology Management
  • Ophthalmic Professional
  • Presbyopia Physician
  • Retinal Physician
The Ophthalmologist
  • Explore

    Explore

    • Latest
    • Insights
    • Case Studies
    • Opinion & Personal Narratives
    • Research & Innovations
    • Product Profiles

    Featured Topics

    • Anterior Segment
    • Glaucoma
    • Retina

    Issues

    • Latest Issue
    • Archive
  • Subspecialties
    • Cataract
    • Cornea
    • Glaucoma
    • Neuro-ophthalmology
    • Oculoplastics
    • Pediatric
    • Retina
  • Business

    Business & Profession

    • Professional Development
    • Business and Entrepreneurship
    • Practice Management
    • Health Economics & Policy
  • Training & Education

    Career Development

    • Professional Development
    • Career Pathways

    Events

    • Webinars
    • Live Events
  • Events
    • Live Events
    • Webinars
  • Community

    People & Profiles

    • Power List
    • Voices in the Community
    • Authors & Contributors
  • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
Subscribe
Subscribe

False

Advertisement
The Ophthalmologist / Issues / 2023 / Oct / Eye, Robot
Research & Innovations Health Economics and Policy

Eye, Robot

Ophthalmologists were able to discern human from AI-generated responses with 61 percent accuracy

By Sarah Healey 10/20/2023 2 min read

Share

Eye Image Credit: Pixabay.com

Large language models (LLMs), such as BERT and GPT-3, have transformed how computers process and understand language. Trained on vast amounts of text, these models have found diverse applications in healthcare, particularly in specialties such as radiology that are data-heavy and image-focused (1).

One standout among these models is ChatGPT, an AI-powered LLM developed by OpenAI and built on GPT-3.5. Since its release in November 2022, the chatbot has worked to simplify radiology reports, write discharge summaries, and transcribe patient notes (2).

Despite revolutionizing the medical landscape, a rise in medical misinformation has caused a major concern about the safety and reliability of LLM chatbots, especially in niche specialties such as ophthalmology.

To better explore the clinical effectiveness of AI-powered technologies, US-based researchers compared the quality of ophthalmic advice generated by an LMM chatbot with those of board-certified ophthalmologists (2).

Patient questions were selected from over 700 pages of The Eye Care Forum, which provides users with answers from physicians affiliated with the American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO). These questions were subsequently put into ChatGPT, and added to a data set ensuring each question had an answer from a human ophthalmologist and the chatbot.

In total, 200 pairs of questions and answers were evaluated. A board of eight ophthalmologists were able to discern human from AI-generated responses with 61 percent accuracy. However, chatbot answers were not perceived to be significantly more harmful than human responses in relation to incorrect information, likelihood and extent of causing harm, and agreement with perceived consensus in the medical community.

The results seem to suggest that LLMS can, in fact, provide astute and appropriate ophthalmic advice to patient queries of varying complexity. So, will there come a time when AI technologies fully replace physicians for some tasks?

References

  1. H Grewal et al., “Radiology Gets Chatty: The ChatGPT Saga Unfolds,” Cureus, [Online ahead of print] (2023). PMID: 37425598. 
  2. I A Bernstein et al., “Comparison of Ophthalmologist and Large Language Model Chatbot Responses to Online Patient Eye Care Questions,” JAMA Netw Open, [Online ahead of print] (2023). PMID: 37606922. 

About the Author(s)

Sarah Healey

Communicating stories in a way that is accessible to all was one of the focal points of my Creative Writing degree. Although writing magical realism is a fun endeavor (and one I still dabble in), getting to the heart of human stories has always been the driving motivator behind my writing. At Texere, I am able to connect with the people behind scientific breakthroughs and share their stories in a way that is impactful and engaging.

More Articles by Sarah Healey

Related Content

Newsletters

Receive the latest Ophthalmology news, personalities, education, and career development – weekly to your inbox.

Newsletter Signup Image

False

Advertisement

False

Advertisement

Explore More in Ophthalmology

Dive deeper into the world of Ophthalmology. Explore the latest articles, case studies, expert insights, and groundbreaking research.

False

Advertisement
The Ophthalmologist
Subscribe

About

  • About Us
  • Work at Conexiant Europe
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 Texere Publishing Limited (trading as Conexiant), with registered number 08113419 whose registered office is at Booths No. 1, Booths Park, Chelford Road, Knutsford, England, WA16 8GS.

Disclaimer

The Ophthalmologist website is intended solely for the eyes of healthcare professionals. Please confirm below: