Conexiant
Login
  • Corneal Physician
  • Glaucoma Physician
  • New Retinal Physician
  • Ophthalmology Management
  • Ophthalmic Professional
  • Presbyopia Physician
  • Retinal Physician
The Ophthalmologist
  • Explore

    Explore

    • Latest
    • Insights
    • Case Studies
    • Opinion & Personal Narratives
    • Research & Innovations
    • Product Profiles

    Featured Topics

    • Anterior Segment
    • Glaucoma
    • Retina

    Issues

    • Latest Issue
    • Archive
  • Subspecialties
    • Cataract
    • Cornea
    • Glaucoma
    • Neuro-ophthalmology
    • Oculoplastics
    • Pediatric
    • Retina
  • Business

    Business & Profession

    • Professional Development
    • Business and Entrepreneurship
    • Practice Management
    • Health Economics & Policy
  • Training & Education

    Career Development

    • Professional Development
    • Career Pathways

    Events

    • Webinars
    • Live Events
  • Events
    • Live Events
    • Webinars
  • Community

    People & Profiles

    • Power List
    • Voices in the Community
    • Authors & Contributors
  • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
Subscribe
Subscribe

False

Advertisement
The Ophthalmologist / Issues / 2018 / Feb / Swallowing Professional Pride
Anterior Segment Cataract Professional Development

Swallowing Professional Pride

Training non-doctors to perform cataract surgery is an obvious approach to tackle cataract blindness

By John Sandford-Smith 2/28/2018 1 min read

Share

Untreated cataract remains the most common cause of blindness in all low-income countries, as well as many middle-income countries. Why, when it is easily, cheaply and quickly treated with good results? In the developing world, where there may be barely one ophthalmologist for 1 million people, the bulk of surgeries become cataract surgeries. But this is not enough to eradicate cataract blindness, and our likely failure to eradicate treatable blindness by 2020 shows that the situation is under-resourced. In my view, the obvious solution is to train non-doctors (such as nurses). Many people have suggested this approach, and some countries, mostly in Africa, have accepted it. There are many advantages of training non-doctor cataract surgeons:

  • Both the undergraduate academic training and postgraduate practical training are much shorter and less costly.
  • Such a person is more likely to stay in the rural areas where they are needed rather than migrating to the big cities.
  • Having had less training and less qualifications, they are likely to be content with a lower salary scale and less likely to emigrate.
  • Because the training is more focused and intensive, their surgical results should be as good if not better than the “fully” trained ophthalmic surgeon.
In modern slang, it would be considered a “no-brainer” in those countries where there is still a huge backlog of cataract blindness. But the idea remains a controversial one, and I don’t understand why. I have been involved in training “nurse cataract surgeons” in Africa, and could see little difference in their skills compared with those of the local ophthalmologists or with my own. Unfortunately, in some instances, although the government accepted this training, the local ophthalmologists were often very unsupportive, and in one case plainly obstructive. One would like to think that the reason for this opposition was to maintain professional standards. However, numerous audits have shown that the surgical results of a properly trained nurse cataract surgeon are just as good as those of an ophthalmologist.  I believe the opposition comes from more subtle causes. It could relate to professional rivalries; some ophthalmologists may feel like they have to preserve their privileged position (and income) after many years of training and education. Ophthalmologists may also be fearful that nurse cataract surgeons may take away some of their business. But in these underserved countries, there is potentially more than enough work for everyone. Unfortunately, ophthalmologists in developing countries often face challenging situations: government salaries are low and government hospitals often dispiriting places in which to work, and the only social security is the extended family. This usually means entering the very competitive – and sometimes ‘cutthroat’ – private practice market in the big cities to maximize one’s income.

For the most part, the boundaries between duties and responsibilities of doctors and nurses are blurred in both rich and poor countries. For instance, in the USA, nurses can be trained to administer anesthetics, but most routine births are delivered by obstetricians. By contrast in the UK, anesthetics are always given by doctors, and nearly all babies are delivered by midwives. In my own postgraduate teaching hospital in Leicester (UK), most carpal tunnel surgery is now performed by a specifically trained nurse rather than an orthopedic surgeon. His audited results have always been excellent, and he has probably performed more carpal tunnel surgery than anyone else in Britain. It is high time for us to swallow our professional pride and accept that where there is a desperate shortage of fully trained specialists, that anyone who has been properly trained and accredited is the right person to do the work. An ophthalmologist does not just perform cataract extractions, and there is still a great deal of other needy work for the fully qualified surgeon to undertake.

About the Author(s)

John Sandford-Smith

John Sandford-Smith is an emeritus Consultant Ophthalmologist at Leicester Royal Infirmary. He is a widely-respected expert on eye diseases and has been extensively involved in teaching, training and voluntary work, both during his career and since his retirement in 2000. In 2007, he received an MBE for services to blind people in developing countries.

More Articles by John Sandford-Smith

Related Content

Newsletters

Receive the latest Ophthalmology news, personalities, education, and career development – weekly to your inbox.

Newsletter Signup Image

False

Advertisement

False

Advertisement

Explore More in Ophthalmology

Dive deeper into the world of Ophthalmology. Explore the latest articles, case studies, expert insights, and groundbreaking research.

False

Advertisement
The Ophthalmologist
Subscribe

About

  • About Us
  • Work at Conexiant Europe
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 Texere Publishing Limited (trading as Conexiant), with registered number 08113419 whose registered office is at Booths No. 1, Booths Park, Chelford Road, Knutsford, England, WA16 8GS.

Disclaimer

The Ophthalmologist website is intended solely for the eyes of healthcare professionals. Please confirm below: